The Bullish Case for Tezos Written by BowTiedTruther.xtz
Level 3 - DeFi Virgin Analyst
Welcome Avatar! We have a guest post today from BowTiedTruther under the handle “BowTiedTruther”, here is the link to his/her twitter handle (LINK). This is a free post for a couple of reasons: 1) we did not write any of the content from the article, 2) we are *NOT* involved in Tezos - while we looked into it at ~$1 we never pulled the trigger and 3) we’re more than happy to hear bull/bear arguments for certain coins if the writing is well researched. This is a bullish post based on his/her opinion
Based on our short discussions with the anon, he’s looking to move his career towards crypto as well. If anyone is hiring/interested you can shoot over a message via twitter (from the prior link).
Final note, if you *disagree* with anything here (bullish/bearish) you’re free to leave a comment. One of the main values of this community/group is you never know who you’ll meet. Some anons are already working together on various niche projects! As usual we hope you get rich!
Tezos from BowTiedTruther (LINK)
Thank you to BowTiedBull and the DeFi team for giving me this opportunity to share some of my knowledge with an overview, valuation and beginner’s guide of Tezos and its ecosystem. I have a strong belief that other smart contract platforms (such as Tezos) have a place to exist in the future with widespread adoptability outside of just Ethereum (even if Ethereum continues to be the leader in the space due to first mover advantage).
Quick Overview of Tezos: Tezos is a public, open-source, self-amending smart contract protocol, based on a liquid proof of stake consensus model and allowing for digital asset transactions and smart contracts execution. The network officially went live in 2018 known as the Genesis block (the network has upgraded 7 times since then and is currently on the Granada block) and the native currency on the Tezos blockchain is the Tez (symbol: XTZ). Expanded detail regarding on-chain governance, LPOS, Delegation can be found here: (LINK)
Tezos was founded by Arthur and Kathleen Breitman (married) and the money raised in the ICO was provided to the Tezos Foundation that is overseen by a committee/board with a variety of cryptoindustry experts. The Tezos Foundation helps oversee the Tezos ecosystem and part of the role it plays is the issuance of grants to prospective new platforms and protocols. The Tezos Foundation currently manages over $1.2 billion which is used for grants, awareness, development, marketing, etc
Valuation: Figured I would cut straight to the juicy part first. I have found the best way to value smart contract platforms would be a multiple of their usage, which can be quantified by smart contract calls (“SCC”). Another way you could value these platforms is applying a multiple of TVL across the entire network, but those numbers are often inflated and not always accurate. Below is a comparison of valuations for Ethereum and Tezos:
At the time of writing, Ethereum trades at a higher multiple of smart contract calls compared to Tezos. This makes sense given the fact that Ethereum’s network is much larger than Tezos and has the most widespread adoption. However, the growth in smart contract calls has slowed across Ethereum as seen in the chart below (Ethereum is currently at ~3.2M SCC per day):
Tezos on the other hand is seeing exponential growth across the network and is currently averaging ~190k smart contract calls per day:
In a simple forecast using a daily run-rate of 190k SCC per day, Tezos in September is likely to reach 5.7M+ smart contract calls. Growing 35% monthly the remainder of 2021 will mean Tezos reaches 14M smart contract calls in the month of December.
As a result, by year end Tezos should theoretically be valued at $23.49 per Tez.
For those who enjoy sensitivity tables, see below what Tezos could theoretically be valued at across various monthly smart contract call volumes and multiples. If you assume that there would be multiple expansion from Tezos becoming a larger network with higher usage, the valuation of $23.49 by year end 2021 at a 1.4x multiple looks extremely conservative (again, Ethereum’s multiple of SCC is 3.2x):
To close this section out, below are some interesting metrics on Tezos and Ethereum at the time of writing. Ethereum Daily Transactions (1.2M): (LINK) Ethereum Daily SCC (3.2M): (LINK) Tezos Daily Transactions (667k, almost 60% of Ethereum's): (LINK) Tezos Daily SCC (190k): (LINK)
Smart Contract Calls: Interaction with a smart contract, for example, initiating a “Harvest All” of farming rewards. Transactions: On chain transactions, for example, after initiating a “Harvest All” for rewards, if you are providing to liquidity to 3 different pairs then your rewards will be sent to you in 3 separate transactions
Secure Smart Contracts: the process of formal verification, based on Michelson programming language, provides the mathematical proof of the correctness of the contract, that can be verified automatically. It is the golden standard of "trustless" guarantee in a blockchain system. (LINK).
Participative Governance: "Bakers" can submit and/or vote on a propose due to the very efficient on-chain formal voting procedure (LINK). By extension, all Tez holders can express their opinion by delegating their Tez to a Baker that shares the same view on a given subject (to consult the voting history of a given baker, click on a baker from the (LINK) then access the "voting" tab)
Proven Upgradeable Network without Forks: Tezos’ formal on-chain governance model has already allowed for 7 (yes, 7) smooth, successful upgrades of the Tezos protocol and lets Tezos stay on top of innovation (Granada was the most recent upgrade:
This is a major advantage over other blockchains and gives Tezos the ability to quickly incorporate proven features of other chains (saplings: LINK) or innovate with proprietary upgrades (liquidity baking: LINK). Additional notable upgrades include reduction of gas fees and block times (now 30 seconds), TPS (now around 200): LINK
While all this is great, what makes Tezos exciting is that there are always additional network improvements on the horizon, specifically the TenderBake upgrade coming sometime in Q4 2021/Q1 2022 will push that up to 1000 TPS and near instant finality meaning block times will be 1 second or less (LINK)
Energy-efficient/Low gas fees: Tezos has been quoted at being 8000x less expensive and more energy efficient than its peer Ethereum. POS requires significantly less energy than POW (which is part of the reason Ethereum is looking to upgrade to ETH 2.0) (LINK).
POS Staking and Deflationary Economics: At each block, 80 new Tezos are created and distributed to the bakers and then to respective delegators. Currently you can earn between 5%-6% in rewards by staking your Tezos with a baker with ~80% of all Tezos currently staked (you can delegate your Tezos to a baker through Ledger Live, for example). You can also stake with centralized custodians such as Coinbase, but as the saying goes “not your keys, not your coins” and they also take a hefty fee leaving you with closer to 4% returns. The big misconception with the POS concept is that many people confuse Tezos with being inflationary (they think in % terms) when in reality the % will decrease over time because it is based on the amount of Tezos created at each block, which over time is divided by a larger Total Supply (i.e. Tezos is deflationary). As many of you are aware, Ethereum is attempting to switch to POS with ETH 2.0, so it is a similar concept but extremely hard to implement without having to fork the network. In the last section of this post, I provide an overview for beginners looking to stake their Tezos and earn 5-6%, which is a safe and secure way to earn a modest return.
The recent Granada proposal that went live at the end of July added a new DEX contract to the Tezos protocol between Tez and tzBTC. This contract is unique because the protocol itself creates additional Tez at every block (2.5) and adds them to the contract. This incentivizes users to provide liquidity to the contract in order to capture a portion of the subsidy (this added bonus to liquidity providers is set to expire 6 months after the upgrade went, so it is not permanent). Further detail on liquidity baking can be found here: LINK.
I’m Intrigued, Where Do I Start?
All major CEX allow you to trade Tezos – if you’re looking for DEX/AMM I would point you to Plenty (LINK) and Quipuswap (LINK). Kukai (LINK) and Temple (LINK) are great wallets to use (similar to Metamask) that allow you to manage your Tezos and various FA1.2 and FA2 tokens (which are Tezos’ equivalent to ERC20 / ERC 721 tokens, although FA2 has NFT capabilities for example, so it is not apples to apples). I typically link my Ledger Nano to Kukai which allows me to 1) view my Tezos and FA1.2/FA2 tokens and 2) interact with platforms such as Plenty to stake/farm/trade at extremely low gas fees (we are talking gas fees in USD pennies). If you have ERC20 tokens, you have the ability to WRAP those onto the Tezos network (examples include: wLINK, wAAVE, wWETH, wWBTC, wBUSD, wUSDC, wMATIC, etc.), you can actually do that on Bender Labs’ WRAP platform (LINK). It is extremely easy and is an efficient way to get 5 your tokens onto the Tezos network to start playing around with DeFi on Tezos and earn high interest from farming.
Below is a screencap of some (not all) of the farming options offered by Plenty – I encourage you to visit their site and poke around. Right now, Plenty offers high rewards in the form of Plenty DAO, which is extremely lucrative at the moment, and I would recommend anyone looking to dip their toes in DeFi to give this a shot. APRs currently are in the high 300%-400% (these APRs are not updated to reflect the temporary double rewards that are shown in the picture below so it is even higher at the moment). You will be amazed at how far less expensive it is to use DeFi on Tezos versus Ethereum which makes it more fun to interact with (again, gas fees are pennies). Even if you believe that Ethereum will hold the throne in the realm long term, you can still earn a significant amount of Plenty and exchange it over time to your favorite ERC-20 tokens that are wrapped on Tezos, and then unwrap them onto the Ethereum network (although once you see the fee difference between Tezos and Ethereum you may not want to!).
QuipuSwap is also a great reliable DEX that is similar to Plenty. Personally, I have found Plenty a bit easier to use and the rewards are better than any other DEX built on Tezos (QuipuSwap does offer a few more trading pairs at the moment). Again, providing liquidity has its risk of impairment loss, but currently the reward potential seems to outweigh that risk at least in the near term. APRs of 300%+ you should be yelling sign me up!
Additionally, Kolibri (LINK) is a lending platform that you can borrow kUSD with Tezos as collateral (BTB has touched on this strategy before, it is risky, but the same concept applies to what you can do in various ways on the Ethereum network). There are various other DeFi platforms that are listed in the below Ecosystem chart that you can do research on and play around with as well.
Broader Tezos Ecosystem: As you will see below, the Tezos ecosystem is robust and flourishing with many different platforms and projects across a variety of buckets. One recent notable partnership that is noteworthy is the 6 launch of OneOf (LINK), a green NFT platform built on Tezos that connects artists and fans via NFTs. This partnership highlights the focus on the “Green”/energy efficient movement a lot of companies have and exemplifies that Tezos is the perfect network for that (in addition to its other advantages). Adoption of NFTs on Tezos have been exponential, those that currently are in the space might be familiar with Hic Et Nunc (which means "here and now") (LINK) which is the most popular NFT marketplace on Tezos. For those looking to get into NFTs on Tezos, I would start here.
Another recent platform that just launched is Homebase (LINK), a web application that enables users to create and manage/use DAOs on the Tezos blockchain. This application aims to help empower community members and developers to launch and participate in Tezos-based DAO’s. An entire post can be written about DAO’s in general, but this highlights the continued adoptability of Tezos as well as the various ways smart contract platforms are disrupting society (in addition to DeFi, NFTs, stablecoins, STOs, etc.).
But what about Solana/DOT/Cardano?
These platforms do share (according to their white papers) some similar characteristics to Tezos. One thing that makes them really stand out in the broader market is the incredible amount of marketing that each network and their teams have done. However, as many of you know, the hype created around coins often outweighs the actual fundamental value until the platform can actually prove out the concept and execute. Marketing, roadmaps, and hype only end up working for so long unless there is actual adoption of the network. At some point, these platforms will either succeed or fall hard on their face. Tezos on the other hand has taken a different approach over the past 3 years and instead focused on building out a strong ecosystem that has tangible widespread use (second to Ethereum as far as daily/monthly smart contract calls which is the main indicator of a smart contract network usage). Keep in mind that smart contract calls and transactions are two different things and are often times confused as being the same. The Tezos strategy of choosing to build out a network (first) and marketing (second) has been a point of contention within the Tezos community (the contention being the lack of marketing) which many people attribute slow price/valuation action, but the reality is Tezos is fully functional while many other smart contract networks are still a white paper / roadmap with far less adoption.
What does that mean for you? You have the potential to enter a fully functioning smart contract platform that is seeing exponential growth at a steep relative value discount to where these other peer networks are trading. Cardano does not currently have smart contract capabilities (still a promise on the roadmap and in the whitepaper). Polkadot (copy pasta of ETH) is still in its testnet phase. Solana (copy pasta of ETH) is valued at $50B+ and claims to have a functioning network but can’t seem to provide public smart contract call level data. Tezos, in comparison, has a strong fundamentally established network, has proven its ability to upgrade the network with its self-amending protocol, high-profile partnerships, exponential growth via monthly smart contract calls (due to growth across DeFi, NFTs, Stablecoins, and STOs), and a solid decentralized foundation / team. I am not suggesting that these other networks won’t also continue to see success, but Tezos is a great investment considering its development over the past 3 years.
Lastly, of the many partnerships that Tezos has (for example, Red Bull Racing), the one with the New York Mets (and subsequent mainstage advertisement in the stadium each game) is no coincidence. A quick Google of who the Mets owner is should have you chomping at the bit
*Helpful Link 1 on why Tezos is differentiated from Ethereum and all its copies (highly recommend): LINK
Quote: “I think we need a new term: Ethereum extenders. Because that is what they are doing. They all use the EVM and solidity. They copy paste Ethereum dapps. They inherit all the strengths and all the weaknesses of Ethereum. They are Ethereum. They are derivatives of Ethereum. (Spoiler alert: These chains exist primarily to overcome Ethereum’s gas costs. What happens to all these EVMs when layer 2 matures or Eth 2 is launched?) Just like we have Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Gold, and Bitcoin Satoshi’s vision (not to mention all the other clones without Bitcoin in the name). We also have Ethereum, Ethereum 2 (Polkadot), Ethereum 3 (Binance), Ethereum 4 (Avax), Ethereum 5 (Tron), Ethereum 6 (Near), Ethereum 7 (Solana)…and on and on.” (LINK)
Links to Q&A/Platforms/Wallets/References: For those who are interested in taking the deep dive into Tezos after reading this post, I have provided below a list of various resources that should be helpful in getting started and more acclimated. This list is by no means exhaustive. The Tezos Reddit thread, Twitter, Discord, etc. are also great resources. (See first BTB comment due to email length issues)
Disclaimer: None of this is to be deemed legal or financial advice of any kind. Example. According to text books, government bonds are risk free.
These are *opinions* written by an anonymous group of Ex-Wall Street Tech Bankers who moved into affiliate marketing and e-commerce.
Daily Reminder: You ARE EARLY. Too much negativity/cope. Everyone reading this is extremely early. 0.1428571429% of the world population has a Metamask wallet. Tiny.
Links to Q&A/Platforms/Wallets/References (Written by BowTiedTruther)
For those who are interested in taking the deep dive into Tezos after reading this post, I have provided
below a list of various resources that should be helpful in getting started and more acclimated. This
list is by no means exhaustive. The Tezos Reddit thread, Twitter, Discord, etc. are also great resources.
Recommended Tezos wallets
▪ List of recommended wallets: https://tezos.com/learn/store-and-use/
▪ Popular wallets: Kukai (https://wallet.kukai.app/), works on mobile browsers), Temple
(https://templewallet.com/) (both allow you to link via Ledger Nano)
▪ Be sure to use the links provided on the Tezos.com page, beware of phishing sites
Staking on Tezos (Baking and Delegating)
▪ How does Baking work?
• On the “POS” based blockchain Tezos, holders can participate in the process of
forming blocks and are rewarded for it by staking themselves if they hold enough Tez
(8000 per roll), or by delegating their Tez to a “Baker” while keeping full control of
their Tez : https://baking-bad.org/docs/tezos-staking-for-beginners/)
▪ Where do I stake?
• You choose between several addresses where you can delegate your Tez from a
wallet, by comparing relevant metrics (rewards, free space, voting
history: https://baking-bad.org/docs/where-to-stake-tezos) of different Bakers
(https://baking-bad.org/ or https://tzkt.io/bakers/all or https://tezos-nodes.com/)
• Ledger Live allows you to delegate right from their platform
▪ How long do I have to wait before I get my rewards?
• It takes between 30-40 days to receive the first payout, then every 3 days
▪ How to become a baker on Tezos?
▪ Corporate bakers on Tezos?
• EDF Exaion (https://exaion.edf.fr/en/exaion/our-news/exaion-edf-group subsidiary-becomes-a-tezos-baker)
• Ubisoft (https://twitter.com/ubisoft/status/1384451272992976898)
• Wakam (https://www.wakam.com/tezos_baker/)
• Smartlink (https://www.smartlink.so/baker/) – this is an extremely interesting
project with a lot of potential. You can purchase SMAK on QuipuSwap
currently and on Plenty in the near future.
A few (not all) DeFi platforms on Tezos
▪ Decentralized exchanges (DEX), AMMs, Farming, Liquidity Pools:
• Plenty (https://www.plentydefi.com/swap)
• Quipuswap (https://quipuswap.com/swap)
• Wrap Protocol (https://app.tzwrap.com/wrap)
▪ Lending: Youves (https://app.youves.com/), Kolibri Finance (https://kolibri.finance/)
▪ Stablecoins: USDtz, wUSDT, wUSDC, USDS (Stably), kUSD (Kolibri), uUSD by Youves
(dollar pegged), EURL by Lugh (euro pegged),
NFT platforms/projects on Tezos
▪ What are NFTs, and why Tezos is the best place to mint/collect them (OneOf
▪ McLaren presentation: https://www.mclaren.com/racing/inside-the-mtc/nft-guide/
▪ Red Bull presentation: https://www.redbull.com/ie-en/redbullracing/tezos-joins-as-official blockchain-partner)
▪ NFT Marketplaces:
o Hicetnunc (https://www.hicetnunc.xyz/)
o Objkt (https://objkt.com/)
o Kalamint (https://kalamint.io/)
o Truesy (https://www.truesy.com/)
o Bazaar (https://bazaarnft.xyz/)
o Minterpop (https://minterpop.com/)
▪ Music: OneOf (https://www.oneof.com/), AmplifyX (https://www.amplifyx.com/)
▪ Sport: https://www.goldengoals.io/
▪ Comics: https://interpopcomics.com/home
▪ Trading card games: https://www.pixelpotus.com/
▪ Programmatically randomly generated avatars: https://objkt.com/collection/tezzardz
Other use cases on Tezos
▪ CeFi use cases on Tezos
• Société Générale bank (https://www.societegenerale.com/en/news/press release/first-structured-product-public-blockchain)
• InCore Bank (https://cointelegraph.com/news/swiss-b2b-bank-incore-launches new-tokenization-tool-using-tezos)
• Equisafe investment (https://www.equisafe.io/)
• Aqarchain real estate investment (https://aqarchain.io/)
• MountX real estate investment (https://www.mountx.io/post/mountx-vertalo choose-tezos-for-first-ever-tokenization-of-real-estate-in-mexico)
▪ E-voting: Electis (https://www.electis.io/)
▪ Comics and Gaming: Interpop (https://www.interpop.io/)
Future projects to be excited about
▪ NFTs from exclusive partnerships with Tezos:
• Red Bull Racing (https://www.redbull.com/ca-en/redbullracing/tezos-joins-as official-blockchain-partner)
• McLaren Racing (https://www.mclaren.com/racing/partners/tezos/)
• New York Mets (https://news.tezoscommons.org/tezos-ecosystem-joins-n-y-mets as-new-advertising-partner-f3050e1b569b)
▪ Emergents: trading card game by an impressive team (https://www.emergents.gg/)
▪ Smartlink (escrow, DeFi, marketplace: https://www.smartlink.so/) and Vortex (DEX by
Smartlink): https://blog.smartlink.so/introducing-vortex-next-gen-amm-built-on-tezos 13ab5ee44519)
▪ Juster: Decentralized betting protocol by the Baking Bad team (https://juster.fi/)
▪ Tezos Finance: DeFi, lending (https://tezos.finance/)
News and blockchains statistics
▪ Tezos news: https://xtz.news/
▪ Blockchain activity: https://tzstats.com/ or https://tzkt.io/
▪ Transactions as it happens: https://tzflow.com/
▪ Smart contracts explorer: https://better-call.dev/stats/mainnet/general
▪ Tokens price and statistics: https://analytics.quipuswap.com/overview
▪ Node explorer: https://tezedge.com/#/network
▪ White paper (https://wiki.tezosagora.org/whitepaper/)
▪ Tezos (https://tezos.com/)
▪ Open Tezos (https://opentezos.com/)
▪ Tezos Agora (https://www.tezosagora.org/)
▪ Tezos Commons (https://tezoscommons.org/)
▪ Tezos Ukraine (https://tezos.org.ua/en)
▪ Nomadic Labs (https://www.nomadic-labs.com/)
▪ First steps and general references : https://tezos.com/developer portal/ and https://opentezos.com/
▪ Michelson, Tezos smart contracts language:
o https://tezos.gitlab.io/active/michelson.html and https://tezos.gitlab.io/michelson reference/
▪ High end alternatives to Michelson: Ligo (https://ligolang.org/), SmartPy
(https://smartpy.io/), Archetype (https://archetype-lang.org/)
▪ Octez, implementation of the Tezos software by Nomadic
This is a fantastic breakdown and I will dig deeper into it, prob grab a small bag. Has anyone here in the community taken a dive into what $sushi is doing with their, yet to launch, NFT marketplace called Shoyu? If they can pull it off, it would probably be one of the most comprehensive NFT market sites. All NFTs priced in $sushi might drive some demand for token.